Auto Insurance for Alliston and Simcoe Area
Affordable and reliable Car Insurance tailored to your needs.
Serving drivers in Alliston, Barrie, New Tecumseth, and surrounding areas.
Get competitive rates and customized coverage for your car, truck, or SUV with Doner-Horsley Insurance Brokers. As independent brokers, we compare multiple insurance providers to find you the best protection at the lowest price.
Why Auto Insurance Matters
Make your insurance easier. We care about your safety, protection and getting you the coverage you need for you and your family. Above all, we make the process easy for our clients regardless of your current or past driving record.
We pride ourselves on providing honest service every step of the way, and we are happy to sit down with you to address any concerns or questions you might have.
Our team will spend the time needed to understand exactly what policy you’ll benefit from and will connect you only with reputable insurance companies we trust for their services. You can count on our team to get you the rates you can afford with the coverage you need.
Covers accidents, theft, vandalism, and weather damage
Includes liability protection if you’re at fault in a vehicular accident
Provides medical coverage for you and your passengers in event of accident
Optional rental car & roadside assistance for added peace of mind
Want to learn more about how you can ensure you’re properly protected and lower your car insurance costs? Let us find the best discounts and coverage for you!
What is Included in Car Insurance?
You may be surprised to learn that many choices are available regarding coverage, limits and deductibles. There are also many ways to reduce premiums, such as combining your property and auto insurance, installing theft deterrent equipment, and increasing your deductible.
Third-Party Liability Coverage
This coverage provides you with protection against damages in a car accident. No one means to get into an accident, but in case you do, and you're responsible, this coverage will protect you to help cover the costs to the injured party.
Accident Benefit Coverage
This protection compensates you for medical and rehabilitation costs and lost income if you or your passengers are injured in a car accident, regardless of who's at fault.
Uninsured Automobile Coverage
This protects you and your passengers in case of injury or harm by an uninsured driver.
Collision Coverage
Helps pay for damages to your vehicle in the event of a collision when you are at fault.
Comprehensive Coverage
This protection pays for damages from theft, vandalism, fire, weather-related damage, or hitting a live animal.
Specified Perils Coverage
This coverage protects specific perils named in the policy like, theft, fire, or certain types of specified damage.
All Perils Coverage
Combines Collision and Comprehensive coverage by protecting all perils (events) named in the policy, including collision and non-collision events.
Accident Forgiveness
This coverage forgives your first at-fault accident and maintains your top rate driver status.
Rental Car Coverage
Provides reimbursement for a rental car while your vehicle is being repaired or replaced due to a covered loss.
Why Choose Doner-Horsley for your Car Insurance?
Trusted Local Brokers, Competitive Rates & Personalized Service - That’s the Doner-Horsley Experience.
✔ Compare Quotes from Multiple Providers – We shop around to save you money
✔ Over 100 Years of Experience – Helping Ontario drivers since 1910
✔ Bundle & Save – Combining auto + home insurance can save you up to 20%
✔ Local Claims Support – Hassle-free claims assistance from real people
What Our Clients Say:
“Was looking for Insurance coverage for a modified car that my current broker and any Insurance company I contact declined. I heard about Doner-Horsley Insurance Broker through a friend and am I ever glad I did. Not only did they get coverage on my car. They also save a a lot of money on my home insurance. Doner-Horsley are amazing to deal with. Very quick response times and if they said something would be done by a certain day it was done. I could not be happier with the service I got and highly recommend them.”
— Noah K.
“Good people. Good for small town.”
— Legion G.